Dinner Menu

Calamari & Zucchini

Fresh calamari, buttermilk soaked zucchini moons, red bell pepper rings, seasoned flour, deep fried, house marinara sauce

Fried Mozzarella

Deep fried, hand breaded fresh mozzarella, house red sauce, chiffonade basil, parmesan dusting

Italian Board

Sopressata, prosciutto, calabrese, mixed olives, homemade hot vinegar peppers, giardinera & Italian sharp cheese

Mussels

Sautéed in our marinara sauce or white wine & garlic, grilled Tuscan bread

Mushroom Bruschetta

Tuscan bread, grilled with olive oil, topped with sautéed button mushrooms, garnished with romano cheese

Bleu Cheese & Tomato Bruschetta

Tuscan bread grilled with olive oil, topped with roma tomatoes & bleu cheese crumbles

Stuffed Hungarian Hot Peppers

Homemade sausage stuffed hot peppers, baked with our red sauce & mozzarella cheese

Sautéed Hungarian Hot Peppers

Hot wax peppers sautéed in olive oil & garlic, grilled Tuscan bread

Garlic Cheese Bread

Mancini Bakery Italian bread, garlic butter & mozzarella cheese, oven baked, served with house red sauce

Italian Fried Greens

Escarole sautéed in olive oil & garlic

Greens & Beans

Escarole, white beans, Hungarian hot peppers sautéed in olive oil

Homemade Potato Chips

Thin slices of Yukon Gold potatoes, fried crispy, served with a side of ranch for dipping

Soccy’s Vinegar Peppers

Hungarian hot pepper rings, olive oil, garlic, oregano, vinegar brine

Minestra

Grandma’s family recipe of our house specialty, ham, greens & beans, served with grilled bruschetta

Award Winning Wedding

Our Chef’s recipe of chicken, tiny meatballs, greens & pastina

Muscarella's Salad

Baby greens, blue cheese crumbles, sautéed hot peppers, Italian dressing

Caesar Salad

Romaine, sharp Italian cheese, black olives, croutons, Caesar dressing

Portabella House Salad

Baby greens, grilled portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, feta cheese, choice of dressing

Grilled Chicken Salad

mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, curly fries, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken breast, choice of dressing

Grilled Steak Salad

Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, curly fries, mozzarella cheese, grilled filet tips, choice of dressing

Tomato Caprese Salad

Italian roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basill & mixed olives, extra virgin olive oil drizzle

Salad Additions:
Chicken $5.00
Peppered Tuna $8.00
Filet Tips $8.00
Apricot Glazed Salmon $8.00
Jumbo Tiger Shrimp $8.00

House Italian… Ranch… Bleu Cheese… French… Caesar… Light Italian… Zinfandel… Balsamic… Dijon Vinaigrette… Oil & Vinegar…

Prime Rib Hoagie

Shaved prime rib, sautéed onions, mushrooms & mozzarella, served with creamy horseradish & aujus

Farmer’s Chicken

Grilled chicken breast, Italian fried greens, sautéed hot peppers, house red sauce, mozzarella cheese

Pressed Italian Steak Hoagie

Grilled peppers, onions, mozzarella cheese, house red sauce

Pressed Philly Steak Hoagie

Grilled peppers, onions, mushrooms, melted cheddar

Potsy’s Famous Meatball Splash

Thick sliced Mancini’s bread, house made meatballs, mozzarella, red sauce

Eddie Burger

Italian fried greens, sautéed hot peppers, mozzarella, red sauce

Blue Devil Burger

Hot sauce, Capicola, blue cheese crumbles

Hamburger

Topped with your favorite ‘fixins’

Spaghetti… Capellini… Fettuccine… Linguine… Penne Rigati… Bowties

Potato Gnocchi… Cheese Tortellini… Cavatelli… Gluten Free… Spinach Ravioli

Sauces

Our Traditional “Old World” Red…with meatballs or our homemade loose sausage
Bolognese…traditional Italian red meat sauce
Marinara…meatless sauce diced tomatoes, fresh herbs & Italian cheese
Pink…a light blend of “Old World” red & alfredo sauces
Spicy Red Pepper…a pink sauce of lightly blended marinara & alfredo & red pepper seeds
Vodka…prosciutto & roma tomatoes, sautéed…blended with cream, vodka & parmesan
Sun Dried Tomato…a blend of emulsified sun dried tomatoes, cream, herbs & parmesan
Roasted Pepper…roasted red peppers, chopped & blended in a light cream sauce
Alfredo…our white sauce with the rich flavor of cream & parmesan cheese
Gorgonzola…cream sauce blended with gorgonzola cheese creating a pungent sauce
Olive…a rich cream sauce combining Italian cheese & a variety of Italian olives
d’Oglio…a blend of seasoned extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic & herb
Pesto…fresh basil, garlic & pine nuts pureed in extra virgin olive oils with romano cheese

Pasta Additions

Homemade Meatballs (2) $2.00
Homemade Loose Italian Sausage, “Sharpsville-Style” $3.00
Hot Sausage Link $3.00
Grilled Hot Peppers $3.00
Grilled Portabella Mushrooms $5.00
Italian Greens $5.00
Grilled Chicken Breast & Broccoli Florets $6.00
Primavera-style Italian Vegetables with Grilled Chicken Breast $7.00
Sautéed Calamari with Chili Flakes $7.00
Sautéed Jumbo Tiger Shrimp $7.00
Sautéed Bay Scallops $7.00
Char Grilled Filet Tips & Portabella Mushrooms $8.00
Grilled Peppered Tuna & Asparagus $8.00
“Ala Muscarella-Style”... Italian Greens... Chicken, Filet Tips or Loose Italian Sausage $8.00
Corleone-Style… Grilled Chicken, Portabella Mushrooms, Hot & Roasted Peppers $8.00
Siciliano-Style… Grilled Red & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Mozzarella… choice of Grilled Chicken Breast or Filet Tips $8.00

Three Cheese Baked Ziti

Our creamy house three cheese filling & red sauce, oven baked with meatballs or loose sausage

Lasagna

Our creamy house three cheese filling, layered with lasagna noodles, baked with our red sauce
Baked with loose sausage, bolognese sauce or meatballs $14.00

Muscarella’s Pasta Trio

Lasagna bolognese, chicken parmigiana & fettuccine alfredo

Parmigiana

Breaded chicken or eggplant, fried then baked, mozzarella cheese, house red sauce, served with spaghetti

Filet & Pasta

Grilled sirloin filet tips, spicy red pepper sauce, variety of sweet bell peppers, linguini pasta, oven baked with fresh mozzarella

Tortellini Pomodora

Grilled chicken breast, cheese tortellini, spicy red pepper sauce, variety of sweet bell peppers, baked with fresh mozzarella

Seafood Linguine

Jumbo tiger shrimp, scallops, clams & mussels sautéed in garlic & olive oil or marinara sauce, linguine pasta

Linguine & Clam Sauce

A sautéed mixture of fresh littleneck clams & diced clams, linguine pasta, red or white sauce

Veal & Peppers

Tender, thin sliced veal, sautéed in olive oil & garlic, simmered with peppers in a fresh tomato sauce, gently tossed with gnocchi

Chicken Marsala

Lightly floured chicken breast, sautéed with mushrooms in a rich Italian marsala wine sauce, choice of side

Chicken Piccata

Lightly floured chicken breast sautéed in white wine with fresh lemon, spinach, mushrooms & capers, choice of side

Chicken Francaise

Chicken breast coated in egg batter sautéed with fresh lemon, garlic & spinach, white wine finish, choice of side

Chicken Carbonara

Italian breaded chicken breast, crispy pancetta, peas, egg parmesan cream sauce, fresh bucatini pasta

Veal Piccata

Lightly floured veal scaloppini, sautéed in white wine with fresh lemon, spinach, mushrooms & capers, choice of side

Veal Marsala

Lightly floured veal scaloppini, sautéed with fresh mushrooms in a rich Italian marsala wine sauce, choice of side

Filet Ribiola

8 oz grilled filet mignon, roasted garlic pappardelle, ribiola & truffle cream sauce

Sirlion Tips & Asiago Gnocci

Grilled sirloin tips, caramelized onions, asiago stuffed gnocchi, roasted garlic cream sauce

Pappardelle & Beef Short Rib Ragu

Chianti braised short rib, smoky bacon, wild mushrooms, San Marzano tomatoes, roasted garlic, fresh herbs, ricotta scoop

Tuscan Strip

A hand cut 13 oz. char grilled Black Angus New York strip, sautéed white beans, crispy pancetta, wilted escarole, olive oil & garlic, shaved Italian cheese, Yukon mashed potatoes

Raykie Ribeye

A hand cut 16 oz. Black Angus Ribeye encrusted in sea salt & char grilled, spaghetti with sautéed garlic, olive oil & Hungarian hot peppers

New York Strip & Bleu

13 oz. Black Angus char grilled sirloin, bleu cheese crust, sautéed wild mushrooms, marsala demi glace, Yukon mashed potatoes

Sirlion & Frites

6 oz. chargrilled sirloin, garlic parmesan fries

Filet & Shrimp

6 oz. char grilled sirloin, sautéed jumbo tiger shrimp, scampi sauce & wilted spinach, Yukon mashed potatoes

Chicken & 40 Cloves

Italian breaded & fried chicken breast, olive oil poached whole garlic, white wine stock & fresh parsley pan sauce, choice of side

Chicken Romano

Herb parmesan breaded chicken breast, penne d’oglio, fresh tomato basil finish

Sicilian Salmon

Sea salt & peppercorn seared salmon fillet, wilted spinach, creamy risotto, orange apricot glaze

Wild Mushroom Risotto

Cremini, oyster & shitake mushrooms, black truffles, parmesan risotto