Antipasta

  • Calamari & Zucchini

    $13

    Fresh calamari, buttermilk soaked zucchini moons, red bell pepper rings, seasoned flour, deep fried, house marinara sauce

  • Fried Mozzarella

    $8

    Deep fried, hand breaded fresh mozzarella, house red sauce, chiffonade basil, parmesan dusting

  • Italian Board

    $15

    Assorted Italian meats, mixed olives, homemade hot vinegar peppers, roasted peppers, fig jam & Italian sharp cheese

  • Mussels

    $11

    Sautéed in our marinara sauce or white wine & garlic, grilled Tuscan bread

  • Mushroom Bruschetta

    $8

    Tuscan bread, grilled with olive oil, topped with sautéed button mushrooms, garnished with romano cheese

  • Bleu Cheese & Tomato Bruschetta

    $8

    Tuscan bread grilled with olive oil, topped with roma tomatoes & bleu cheese crumbles

  • Stuffed Hungarian Hot Peppers

    $11

    Homemade sausage stuffed hot peppers, baked with our red sauce & mozzarella cheese

  • Sautéed Hungarian Hot Peppers

    $8

    Hot wax peppers sautéed in olive oil & garlic, grilled Tuscan bread

  • Garlic Cheese Bread

    $9 (Full Loaf)$7 (Half Loaf)

    Mancini Bakery Italian bread, garlic butter & mozzarella cheese, oven baked, served with house red sauce

  • Italian Fried Greens

    $8

    Escarole sautéed in olive oil & garlic

  • Greens & Beans

    $9

    Escarole, white beans, Hungarian hot peppers sautéed in olive oil

  • Homemade Potato Chips

    $6

    Thin slices of Yukon Gold potatoes, fried crispy, served with a side of ranch for dipping

  • Soccy’s Vinegar Peppers

    $6

    Hungarian hot pepper rings, olive oil, garlic, oregano, vinegar brine

Zuppa

  • Minestra

    $4 Cup |$5 Bowl

    Grandma’s family recipe of our house specialty, ham, greens & beans, served with grilled bruschetta

  • Award Winning Wedding

    $4 Cup |$5 Bowl

    Our Chef’s recipe of chicken, tiny meatballs, greens & pastina

Create Your Own Pasta

  • $13

    Spaghetti… Capellini… Fettuccine… Linguine… Penne Rigati… Bowties

  • $15

    Potato Gnocchi… Cheese Tortellini… Cavatelli… Gluten Free… Spinach Ravioli

  • Sauces

    Our Traditional “Old World” Red…with meatballs or our homemade loose sausage
    Bolognese…traditional Italian red meat sauce
    Marinara…meatless sauce diced tomatoes, fresh herbs & Italian cheese
    Pink…a light blend of “Old World” red & alfredo sauces
    Spicy Red Pepper…a pink sauce of lightly blended marinara & alfredo & red pepper seeds
    Vodka…prosciutto & roma tomatoes, sautéed…blended with cream, vodka & parmesan
    Sun Dried Tomato…a blend of emulsified sun dried tomatoes, cream, herbs & parmesan
    Roasted Pepper…roasted red peppers, chopped & blended in a light cream sauce
    Alfredo…our white sauce with the rich flavor of cream & parmesan cheese
    Gorgonzola…cream sauce blended with gorgonzola cheese creating a pungent sauce
    Olive…a rich cream sauce combining Italian cheese & a variety of Italian olives
    d’Oglio…a blend of seasoned extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic & herb
    Pesto…fresh basil, garlic & pine nuts pureed in extra virgin olive oils with romano cheese
    Cacio E Pepe…Black pepper, butter, Pecorino Romano

  • Pasta Additions

    Homemade Meatballs (2)...$2
    Homemade Loose Italian Sausage, “Sharpsville-Style”...$3
    Grilled Chicken Breast & Broccoli Florets...$6
    Sautéed Jumbo Tiger Shrimp (6)...$8
    Sautéed Bay Scallops...$8
    Char Grilled Filet Tips & Portabella Mushrooms...$10
    “Ala Muscarella-Style”... Italian Greens... Chicken, Filet Tips or Loose Italian Sausage...$10
    Corleone-Style… Grilled Chicken, Portabella Mushrooms, Hot & Roasted Peppers...$10
    Siciliano-Style… Grilled Red & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Mozzarella… choice of Grilled Chicken Breast or Filet Tips...$10

  • Pasta Entrées are served with Mancini Italian bread & choice of Garden or Caesar Salad.
    Substitute a Cup of Homemade Soup for $1

    (plate sharing charge $5.00)

Chef Specialties

  • Three Cheese Baked Ziti

    $15

    Our creamy house three cheese filling & red sauce, oven baked with meatballs or loose sausage

  • Lasagna

    $17

    Our creamy house three cheese filling, layered with lasagna noodles, baked with our red sauce
    Baked with loose sausage, bolognese sauce or meatballs $17.00

  • Muscarella’s Pasta Trio

    $20

    Lasagna bolognese, chicken parmigiana & fettuccine alfredo

  • Parmigiana

    $16

    Breaded chicken or eggplant, fried then baked, mozzarella cheese, house red sauce, served with spaghetti

  • Filet & Pasta

    $22

    Grilled sirloin filet tips, spicy red pepper sauce, variety of sweet bell peppers, linguini pasta, oven baked with fresh mozzarella

  • Pappardelle & Beef Short Rib Ragu

    $24

    Chianti braised short rib, smoky bacon, wild mushrooms, San Marzano tomatoes, roasted garlic, fresh herbs, ricotta scoop

  • Tortellini Pomodora

    $19

    Grilled chicken breast, cheese tortellini, spicy red pepper sauce, variety of sweet bell peppers, baked with fresh mozzarella

  • Chicken Marsala

    $19

    Lightly floured chicken breast, sautéed with mushrooms in a rich Italian marsala wine sauce, choice of side

  • Chicken Piccata

    $19

    Lightly floured chicken breast sautéed in white wine with fresh lemon, spinach, mushrooms & capers, choice of side

  • Chicken Francaise

    $19

    Chicken breast coated in egg batter sautéed with fresh lemon, garlic & spinach, white wine finish, choice of side

  • Chicken Carbonara

    $22

    Italian breaded chicken breast, crispy pancetta, peas, egg parmesan cream sauce, fresh bucatini pasta

  • Chicken & 40 Cloves

    $18

    Italian breaded & fried chicken breast, olive oil poached whole garlic, white wine stock & fresh parsley pan sauce, choice of side

  • Chicken Romano

    $17

    Herb parmesan breaded chicken breast, penne d’oglio, fresh tomato basil finish

  • Veal Piccata

    $22

    Lightly floured veal scaloppini, sautéed in white wine with fresh lemon, spinach, mushrooms & capers, choice of side

  • Veal Marsala

    $22

    Lightly floured veal scaloppini, sautéed with fresh mushrooms in a rich Italian marsala wine sauce, choice of side

  • Veal & Peppers

    $23

    Tender, thin sliced veal, sautéed in olive oil & garlic, simmered with peppers in a fresh tomato sauce, gently tossed with gnocchi

  • Wild Mushroom Risotto

    $17

    Cremini, oyster & shitake mushrooms, black truffles, parmesan risotto

  • Chef Specialties are served with Mancini Italian bread & choice of Garden or Caesar Salad.
    Substitute a Cup of Homemade Soup for $1

Insalata

  • Muscarella's Salad

    $12

    Baby greens, blue cheese crumbles, sautéed hot peppers, grilled chicken, Italian dressing

  • Caesar Salad

    $14

    Blackened salmon, romaine, sharp Italian cheese, black olives, croutons, Caesar dressing

  • Portabella House Salad

    $14

    Baby greens, grilled chicken & portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, feta cheese, choice of dressing

  • Grilled Chicken Salad

    $12

    Crispy garlic & herb tortilla shell, mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, curly fries, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken breast, choice of dressing

  • Grilled Steak Salad

    $14

    Crispy garlic & herb tortilla shell, mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, curly fries, mozzarella cheese, grilled filet tips, choice of dressing

  • Tomato Caprese Salad

    $9

    Italian roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basill & mixed olives, extra virgin olive oil drizzle

  • Meatball Insalata

    $10

    Veal, beef & pork house meatballs, house salad, red wine vinaigrette, roasted hot pepper, fresh ricotta

  • House Italian… Ranch… Bleu Cheese… French… Caesar… Light Italian… Zinfandel… Balsamic… Dijon Vinaigrette… Oil & Vinegar…

Hand Helds

  • Prime Rib Hoagie

    $14

    Shaved prime rib, sautéed onions, mushrooms & mozzarella, served with creamy horseradish & aujus

  • Farmer’s Chicken

    $12

    Grilled chicken breast, Italian fried greens, sautéed hot peppers, house red sauce, mozzarella cheese

  • Eddie Burger

    $13

    Italian fried greens, sautéed hot peppers, mozzarella, red sauce

  • Royale with Cheese

    $12

    Two 4oz. beef patties, American cheese, pickles, onions, special sauce, brioche bun
    Add an extra patty +$3

  • Hand Helds are served with choice of fries or homemade chips.
    Substitute a salad or cup of soup for $1

From the Grille

Certified Angus Beef Aged 30 Days, Chargrilled with House Blend Seasonings

  • Sirloin

    $19 (6oz.) | $22 (11 oz.)

  • Charred Ribeye

    $36 (18oz.) | $42 (24oz Bone-In)

  • New York Strip

    $30 (14 oz.)

  • Sirlion Tips & Asiago Gnocci

    $23

    Grilled sirloin tips, caramelized onions, asiago stuffed gnocchi, roasted garlic cream sauce

  • Kobe Burger

    $18

    Caramelized onions, peppered pork belly, fried egg, arugula, roasted garlic Calabrian chili aioli, garlic parmesan fries

  • Sicilian Salmon

    $20

    Sea salt & peppercorn seared salmon fillet, wilted spinach, creamy risotto, orange apricot glaze

  • Grille Selections are served with a choice of side, Mancini Italian bread & choice of Garden or Caesar Salad.
    Substitute a Cup of Homemade Soup for $1

  • Over the Top

    Customize Your Steak with any of these Signature Toppings for $5
    Raykie Style...Hot Peppers, Spaghetti Olive Oil, Garlic & Parmesan
    Tuscan...Pancetta, White Beans, Escarole, Garlic, Butter
    Wild Mushroom...Marsala & Blue Cheese
    Scampi...Shrimp, White Wine Garlic Sauce, Wilted Spinach
    40 Cloves...Whole Poached Garlic Cloves, Garlic, Butter Parmesan Sauce

  • Sides

    Yukon Mashed
    Baked Potato
    Garlic Parmesan Fries
    Vegetables
    Spaghetti Red
    Wild Mushroom Risotto
    +$4
    Seafood Loaded Baked Potato +$6
    (Shrimp, Scallops, Bacon, Smoked Gouda Cream)

Seafood

  • Shrimp Fra Diavolo

    $20

    San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, basil, Calabrian chili peppers, fresh pappardelle

  • Seafood Linguine

    $25

    Jumbo tiger shrimp, scallops, clams & mussels sautéed in garlic & olive oil or marinara sauce, linguine pasta

  • Linguine & Clam Sauce

    $20

    A sautéed mixture of fresh littleneck clams & diced clams, linguine pasta, red or white sauce

  • Seafood Selections are served with Mancini Italian bread & choice of Garden or Caesar Salad.
    Substitute a Cup of Homemade Soup for $1



    Consuming Raw or Undercooked Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish or Eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions..

Print